Reviewer Ethics
Journal of Injury and Violence Research (JIVR)
1. Ethical Principles and Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers
The Journal of Injury and Violence Research (JIVR) considers peer review an essential component of responsible scholarly publishing and the maintenance of scientific integrity.
Peer reviewers play a fundamental role in ensuring the quality, reliability, originality, and ethical acceptability of published research.
JIVR expects all reviewers to conduct their evaluations according to the highest standards of professional integrity, impartiality, confidentiality, accountability, and respect for scientific principles.
This policy is informed by the recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) and the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), particularly the ethical guidelines for peer reviewers.
All individuals accepting invitations to review manuscripts for JIVR are expected to comply with the ethical responsibilities described below.
2. Confidentiality and Protection of Manuscripts
Manuscripts submitted to JIVR are confidential scholarly documents and represent the intellectual property and unpublished work of their authors.
Reviewers must maintain strict confidentiality regarding all manuscripts, supplementary materials, reviewer reports, and editorial communications received during the review process.
Reviewers must not:
-
Disclose manuscript contents or findings to unauthorized individuals.
-
Share manuscripts, figures, tables, supplementary files, or reviewer reports with others without prior authorization from the responsible Editor.
-
Discuss unpublished research publicly or through private professional communications.
-
Distribute manuscript materials through email, messaging applications, social media, or other unauthorized channels.
-
Use information obtained through peer review for personal, academic, professional, or commercial advantage.
-
Retain manuscript copies for personal use after completing the review.
-
Reveal confidential information about editorial discussions or decisions.
The confidentiality obligation remains in effect after the review has been completed and regardless of whether the manuscript is accepted, revised, or rejected.
Reviewers should delete locally downloaded manuscript files and destroy printed copies after submitting their reports, unless retention is required by applicable institutional or legal requirements or explicitly authorized by the journal.
3. Protection of Authors' Intellectual Property
Reviewers must respect the intellectual property rights of manuscript authors.
Ideas, hypotheses, research methods, unpublished findings, datasets, analytical approaches, and other original contributions contained in a submitted manuscript must not be used or appropriated without appropriate authorization.
Reviewers must not:
-
Reproduce unpublished research findings in their own publications without permission.
-
Use authors' unpublished ideas to advance their own research projects.
-
Incorporate confidential manuscript information into their own grant applications or research proposals.
-
Share unpublished findings with collaborators or colleagues for personal or professional benefit.
-
Take advantage of access to manuscripts to gain an unfair academic or competitive advantage.
The responsibility to protect authors' intellectual contributions continues after the review process has ended.
4. Objectivity, Impartiality, and Fair Evaluation
Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively, independently, and without discrimination.
Scientific assessments should be based on the quality, originality, methodology, ethical integrity, and relevance of the research rather than personal preferences or assumptions about the authors.
Reviewers must not be influenced by:
-
Authors' nationality, ethnicity, race, or cultural background.
-
Gender, age, religion, or political beliefs.
-
Institutional affiliation or academic status.
-
Personal relationships or professional rivalries.
-
The country or geographical location in which the research was conducted.
-
Whether the findings support or contradict the reviewer's own research or scientific opinions.
Reviewers should recognize that scientifically valid research may produce negative, unexpected, or controversial findings.
A manuscript must not be judged unfavorably merely because its conclusions differ from the reviewer's own views, provided that the methodology and evidence are scientifically sound.
Reviewers must distinguish between substantive scientific limitations and personal preferences regarding research methods, terminology, or interpretation.
5. Conflicts of Interest and Competing Interests
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived competing interests that could influence, or reasonably appear to influence, their evaluation of a manuscript.
Potential conflicts of interest include:
5.1. Personal Relationships
Family relationships, close friendships, personal disputes, or other relationships with manuscript authors.
5.2. Professional and Institutional Relationships
Current or recent institutional affiliations, employment, supervisory relationships, close collaborations, or professional associations with any of the authors.
5.3. Financial Interests
Research funding, consultancy, employment, honoraria, commercial interests, patents, stock ownership, or other financial relationships relevant to the manuscript.
5.4. Academic and Intellectual Competition
Direct competition involving similar research questions, datasets, research findings, publications, or ongoing investigations.
5.5. Other Relevant Interests
Any personal, institutional, political, ideological, or professional relationship that could compromise the reviewer's independence.
Reviewers must disclose relevant conflicts before accepting a review invitation or as soon as a potential conflict becomes apparent.
When a conflict exists, reviewers should decline the invitation or immediately notify the responsible Editor.
The Editor determines whether the reviewer may proceed with the assessment or must withdraw.
When in doubt, reviewers should seek guidance from the Editorial Office rather than independently deciding that a potential conflict is insignificant.
6. Competence, Expertise, and Responsibility
Reviewers should accept assignments only when they possess sufficient expertise to evaluate the scientific subject matter or methodological aspects of the manuscript.
Before accepting an invitation, reviewers should consider:
-
Whether the research topic falls within their expertise.
-
Whether they can evaluate the relevant study design and methodology.
-
Whether they have sufficient statistical or technical expertise for the requested assessment.
-
Whether they can provide an objective and scientifically useful review.
-
Whether they can complete the review within the agreed timeframe.
If a manuscript includes substantial methodological, statistical, clinical, or technical components outside the reviewer's expertise, this limitation should be clearly communicated to the responsible Editor.
Reviewers should not present opinions outside their area of competence as definitive scientific judgments.
7. Timeliness and Professional Commitment
Reviewers have a professional responsibility to complete accepted assignments within the agreed timeframe.
They should:
-
Respond to review invitations promptly.
-
Accept invitations only when they can reasonably meet the proposed deadline.
-
Inform the responsible Editor as early as possible if additional time is required.
-
Notify the journal promptly if unexpected circumstances prevent completion of the review.
-
Avoid unnecessary delays in the peer-review process.
Reviewers must not intentionally delay the evaluation of manuscripts for personal, competitive, or professional reasons.
The timely completion of peer review supports fairness toward authors and facilitates the responsible dissemination of scientific knowledge.
8. Constructive and Respectful Communication
Reviewer comments must be professional, respectful, objective, and scientifically justified.
Criticism should focus on the manuscript and its scientific content rather than the personal characteristics, academic background, or perceived abilities of the authors.
Reviewers must not use:
-
Insulting, humiliating, or offensive language.
-
Threatening or intimidating statements.
-
Discriminatory or prejudicial comments.
-
Unsupported accusations of research misconduct.
-
Personal attacks or inappropriate criticism.
-
Language intended to undermine an author for personal or professional reasons.
Recommendations should be explained clearly and supported by relevant scientific or methodological reasoning.
Where possible, reviewers should provide constructive suggestions that can help authors improve the quality, clarity, and scientific validity of their work.
9. Appropriate Citation Recommendations
Reviewers may recommend additional references when they are scientifically relevant and necessary to improve the manuscript.
However, reviewers must not:
-
Request unnecessary citations to their own publications.
-
Demand citations to colleagues' publications without a clear scientific justification.
-
Recommend references primarily to increase personal or journal citation metrics.
-
Use citation recommendations to promote their own academic or professional interests.
All suggested references should have a clear scientific relationship to the manuscript.
Reviewers should explain why an additional reference is relevant and how it would improve the scientific discussion.
10. Reporting Suspected Research or Publication Misconduct
Reviewers have an important responsibility to alert the responsible Editor when they identify credible concerns about research integrity or publication ethics.
Potential concerns include:
-
Plagiarism or inappropriate text recycling.
-
Duplicate or redundant publication.
-
Data fabrication or falsification.
-
Inappropriate manipulation of images or figures.
-
Unethical research involving human participants or animals.
-
Missing or questionable ethical approval.
-
Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
-
Inconsistent or potentially unreliable research findings.
-
Citation manipulation.
-
Suspected manipulation of the peer-review process.
-
Other possible breaches of research or publication ethics.
Reviewers should provide clear explanations and relevant evidence when reporting such concerns.
Suspected misconduct should be communicated confidentially to the responsible Editor, preferably through the designated confidential comments section of the review system.
Reviewers must not make unsupported public accusations, independently contact authors to investigate suspected misconduct, or contact authors' institutions without authorization from the journal.
The Editor is responsible for determining the appropriate course of action in accordance with the JIVR Publication Ethics and Research Integrity Policy and relevant COPE guidance.
11. Ethical Use of Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies
JIVR recognizes that artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies may provide support for certain scholarly and editorial activities.
However, the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and the protection of unpublished research information must remain paramount.
Reviewers must not upload, submit, or transfer confidential manuscripts, reviewer reports, supplementary materials, or any identifiable unpublished submission content to public or external AI systems without the journal's explicit prior authorization and appropriate confidentiality and data-protection safeguards.
This restriction applies to, but is not limited to:
-
Generative AI chatbots and large language models.
-
AI-based manuscript summarization platforms.
-
AI-assisted scientific evaluation systems.
-
External grammar and language-processing tools.
-
AI-powered statistical or document-analysis services.
-
Generative image or multimedia tools.
If a reviewer considers AI assistance necessary for a specific part of the review, prior permission must be obtained from the responsible Editor.
Where AI use is authorized, reviewers must:
-
Maintain strict confidentiality of the manuscript and associated materials.
-
Ensure that the tool and its use comply with the journal's authorization and security requirements.
-
Independently verify all AI-generated information.
-
Avoid relying on AI-generated assessments as substitutes for expert scientific judgment.
-
Disclose the authorized use of AI to the responsible Editor.
AI systems must never be listed as reviewers or credited as responsible decision-makers.
Reviewers remain personally responsible for the accuracy, fairness, originality, and scientific integrity of their review reports.
These requirements are consistent with the applicable ICMJE recommendations concerning AI use by reviewers.
12. Use of Assistance During Peer Review
Reviewers are expected to conduct their assigned assessments personally and must not delegate the review to another individual without the prior authorization of the responsible Editor.
If a reviewer wishes to involve a qualified colleague, research trainee, or other specialist in a particular aspect of the assessment, permission must first be obtained from the journal.
Any authorized assistance must:
-
Preserve manuscript confidentiality.
-
Be provided by an appropriately qualified individual.
-
Be limited to the approved scope of assistance.
-
Be disclosed to the responsible Editor.
-
Be acknowledged appropriately in the confidential review communication when required.
The original reviewer remains responsible for the final submitted report and must ensure that the evaluation reflects their own professional judgment.
Unauthorized delegation or disclosure of confidential manuscript materials is unacceptable.
13. Reviewer Anonymity and Personal Disclosure
JIVR employs a double-anonymous peer-review process for manuscripts selected for external review.
Reviewers must not intentionally reveal their identities to authors through review reports, document properties, uploaded files, direct communications, or other means.
Reviewers should avoid including identifying personal information in their comments or attachments unless the journal explicitly authorizes a signed review.
Reviewers must also respect the anonymity of authors and must not attempt to identify them through indirect means.
If a reviewer independently discovers the identity of an author and believes this could affect impartiality, the matter should be disclosed confidentially to the responsible Editor.
14. Reviewer Independence and Editorial Integrity
Reviewers must maintain their independence throughout the peer-review process.
They must not seek to influence editorial decisions through personal, financial, institutional, or professional pressure.
Reviewers must not:
-
Attempt to contact other reviewers to coordinate recommendations without editorial authorization.
-
Seek confidential information about other reviewers' identities or reports.
-
Attempt to influence the Editor outside the formal review process.
-
Misrepresent their expertise or qualifications.
-
Use peer review to delay competing research.
-
Request that authors undertake scientifically unjustified work for personal or professional benefit.
Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final editorial decision remains the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief or responsible Editor.
15. Responsibilities After Completing a Review
The ethical responsibilities of reviewers continue after submission of their reports.
After completing a review, reviewers must:
-
Maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and associated communications.
-
Refrain from using unpublished information for personal advantage.
-
Delete locally retained manuscript files and destroy printed copies, subject to applicable requirements and journal instructions.
-
Avoid discussing the manuscript's confidential contents with unauthorized individuals.
-
Disclose any subsequent conflict of interest if further review or editorial involvement is requested.
Reviewers must not independently communicate editorial decisions or the journal's confidential assessment to authors or third parties.
16. Reporting Reviewer Misconduct
JIVR takes concerns regarding unethical reviewer conduct seriously.
Examples of reviewer misconduct include:
-
Breaching manuscript confidentiality.
-
Misusing unpublished research information.
-
Undisclosed conflicts of interest.
-
Unprofessional or discriminatory review comments.
-
Unauthorized delegation of peer review.
-
Uploading confidential manuscripts to unauthorized AI systems.
-
Deliberately delaying peer review.
-
Citation manipulation.
-
Attempts to influence editorial decisions improperly.
When such concerns arise, the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately appointed independent Editor may assess the available evidence and request an explanation from the reviewer.
Depending on the nature and seriousness of the matter, appropriate actions may include:
-
Requesting clarification.
-
Providing guidance or a formal warning.
-
Reassigning or discontinuing the review.
-
Removing the individual from the journal's reviewer database.
-
Suspending future review invitations.
-
Taking further action in accordance with applicable ethical and institutional requirements.
All concerns should be handled fairly, confidentially, and in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics and Research Integrity Policy.
17. Recognition and Acknowledgement of Reviewers
JIVR recognizes peer review as a valuable scholarly contribution to the academic community.
The journal appreciates the time, expertise, and professional commitment of reviewers who contribute to maintaining scientific quality and publication integrity.
The journal may provide appropriate acknowledgement or certificates of review service, subject to its applicable administrative arrangements and confidentiality requirements.
Reviewer participation does not automatically guarantee certification, payment, or other forms of compensation.
18. International Ethical Standards and Resources
JIVR expects all reviewers to follow internationally recognized standards of responsible peer review.
The following resources are recommended:
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)
Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals.
https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/
ICMJE – Responsibilities in the Submission and Peer-Review Process
ICMJE – Use of AI by Reviewers
https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/browse/artificial-intelligence/ai-use-by-reviewers.html
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
Core Practices.
https://publicationethics.org/core-practices
COPE – Ethical Guidelines for Peer Reviewers
https://publicationethics.org/resources/guidelines/cope-ethical-guidelines-peer-reviewers
Reference to these organizations and their recommendations does not, by itself, imply formal membership or accreditation.
19. Contact for Reviewer Ethics Concerns
Reviewers who have questions regarding ethical responsibilities, confidentiality, competing interests, AI-assisted technologies, or other professional matters should contact the Editorial Office.
Concerns or allegations regarding unethical conduct during the peer-review process should be communicated confidentially to the Editor-in-Chief or the appropriate independent editorial authority.
Journal of Injury and Violence Research (JIVR)
Editorial Office
Email: jivr1@jivresearch.org
Website: https://jivresearch.org/jivr/
JIVR appreciates the commitment of its reviewers to confidentiality, fairness, independence, and the highest standards of scientific and publication ethics.