Publication Ethics
PUBLICATION ETHICS AND RESEARCH INTEGRITY POLICY
Journal of Injury and Violence Research (JIVR)
1. Ethical Principles and Standards
The Journal of Injury and Violence Research (JIVR) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics, scientific integrity, transparency, and responsible scholarly communication.
The journal is guided by the recommendations of the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), the Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), and other internationally recognized standards of responsible research and scholarly publishing.
JIVR expects authors, editors, reviewers, editorial board members, and all other participants in the publication process to act with honesty, fairness, accountability, and professional integrity.
The journal does not tolerate research misconduct, unethical publication practices, or any behavior that compromises the reliability of the scientific record.
Editorial decisions are based on scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, ethical acceptability, and relevance to the journal's aims and scope.
This policy applies to all stages of the publication process, including manuscript preparation, submission, peer review, editorial evaluation, publication, and post-publication activities.
2. Responsibilities of Authors
Authors are responsible for ensuring the originality, accuracy, transparency, and ethical integrity of their submitted work.
By submitting a manuscript to JIVR, authors confirm that:
-
The manuscript represents original scholarly work.
-
All sources, data, ideas, and materials obtained from other individuals or publications have been appropriately acknowledged.
-
The research has been conducted in accordance with applicable ethical and scientific standards.
-
The results are accurately reported and are not fabricated, falsified, or misleadingly presented.
-
All listed authors meet the journal's authorship requirements.
-
All authors have reviewed and approved the submitted version.
-
Relevant funding and competing interests have been disclosed.
-
Required ethical approvals and informed consent have been obtained, where applicable.
-
Clinical trial registration requirements have been fulfilled, where applicable.
-
A Data Availability Statement has been included in the manuscript.
-
Any relevant use of AI-assisted technologies has been disclosed.
-
The manuscript is not under simultaneous consideration by another journal.
Authors must respond appropriately to editorial inquiries and provide additional documentation when reasonably requested.
Any serious concerns regarding the accuracy or integrity of the submitted work must be addressed transparently.
3. Authorship and Contributorship
JIVR follows the four authorship criteria established by the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE).
All individuals designated as authors must satisfy all four criteria:
-
Substantial Contribution: Making substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, or the acquisition, analysis, or interpretation of data.
-
Manuscript Preparation: Drafting the work or reviewing it critically for important intellectual content.
-
Final Approval: Providing final approval of the version to be published.
-
Accountability: Agreeing to be accountable for all aspects of the work and ensuring that questions related to the accuracy or integrity of any part of the work are appropriately investigated and resolved.
Individuals who meet some but not all four criteria must not be listed as authors. Their contributions may be appropriately acknowledged with their permission.
JIVR does not accept:
-
Guest Authorship: Listing individuals as authors who have not made sufficient scholarly contributions to meet all authorship criteria.
-
Gift Authorship: Granting authorship based solely on academic position, seniority, institutional authority, or financial support.
-
Ghost Authorship: Omitting individuals who have made substantial contributions and meet the authorship criteria.
-
Undisclosed Writing Assistance: Concealing material contributions from professional medical writers or other contributors.
Author contributions should be transparently described, preferably using the Contributor Roles Taxonomy (CRediT), where applicable.
Any proposed changes to authorship after submission must be justified in writing and approved by all affected authors, including individuals being added or removed.
Disputes concerning authorship eligibility or contribution should ordinarily be investigated by the institutions where the research was conducted. JIVR may request institutional clarification or documentation but does not ordinarily arbitrate institutional authorship disputes.
4. Research Involving Human Participants
All research involving human participants, identifiable human data, or human biological materials must comply with applicable ethical requirements and internationally recognized principles of research ethics.
JIVR expects authors to follow the relevant principles of the World Medical Association's Declaration of Helsinki (2024), together with applicable national and institutional regulations.
Authors must provide appropriate information concerning:
-
Research Ethics Committee or Institutional Review Board approval.
-
The name of the approving institution.
-
The ethical approval or reference number.
-
The date of approval, where available.
-
Informed consent procedures.
-
Any approved waiver of informed consent.
Ethical approval must be obtained before research begins whenever required by applicable regulations and institutional requirements.
A statement claiming exemption from ethical review must be supported by an appropriate determination from a competent institutional or regulatory authority.
Authors must not independently declare their own research exempt from ethical review without appropriate authorization.
Ethics committee approval does not automatically guarantee that all aspects of a study were conducted ethically. JIVR may request additional information when concerns arise regarding participant protection or research conduct.
4.1. Informed Consent
Authors must ensure that informed consent has been obtained from research participants or their legally authorized representatives whenever required.
For research involving children or individuals who cannot provide legally valid consent, appropriate parental or legally authorized representative permission and participant assent procedures must be described.
Where informed consent has been waived by an ethics committee, the waiver and its justification must be reported.
4.2. Consent for Publication
Written consent for publication is required when manuscripts contain identifiable personal information, clinical photographs, images, or other information that could allow an individual to be identified.
Consent to participate in research does not automatically constitute consent for publication of identifiable information.
Authors are responsible for protecting participant privacy and avoiding unnecessary identifying details.
4.3. Vulnerable Populations and Sensitive Research
Research involving children, survivors of violence, victims of abuse, individuals experiencing trauma, prisoners, individuals with impaired decision-making capacity, and other vulnerable populations requires particular ethical attention.
Authors must demonstrate that appropriate safeguards were implemented to protect participants' dignity, autonomy, confidentiality, psychological well-being, and physical safety.
Research involving survivors of violence, self-harm, or suicide-related experiences should include appropriate procedures for minimizing psychological distress, preventing further harm, and protecting sensitive personal information.
The journal may request additional explanations when participant protection or ethical procedures are unclear.
5. Research Involving Animals
Research involving animals must comply with applicable institutional, national, and international animal welfare regulations.
Authors must provide information about:
-
Animal ethics committee approval.
-
Institutional approval number, where applicable.
-
Animal species, strain, and relevant characteristics.
-
Housing and experimental conditions.
-
Procedures used to minimize pain, suffering, and distress.
-
Methods of euthanasia, where applicable.
The principles of Replacement, Reduction, and Refinement (the 3Rs) should be considered in the design and conduct of animal research.
Authors are encouraged to follow the ARRIVE reporting guidelines.
JIVR may request additional documentation concerning animal welfare and ethical approval when necessary.
6. Clinical Trial Registration
JIVR follows applicable ICMJE recommendations concerning clinical trial registration.
Clinical trials must be registered in a publicly accessible clinical trial registry acceptable under ICMJE requirements at or before the time of first participant consent for enrollment.
Authors must disclose:
-
The name of the clinical trial registry.
-
The unique registration number.
-
The public registry URL.
-
The date on which registration materials were first submitted.
The registration information must be included in the manuscript and abstract, as applicable.
Retrospective registration does not replace prospective registration. Delayed registration must be transparently disclosed and is subject to editorial assessment.
Ethical approval and clinical trial registration are separate requirements and do not replace one another.
7. Research Data Integrity, Availability, and Reproducibility
JIVR considers research data integrity an essential component of responsible scientific publication.
Authors must ensure that the data supporting their findings are accurate, appropriately collected, analyzed, documented, and reported.
Every manuscript submitted to JIVR must contain a Data Availability Statement in the Declarations section immediately before the References.
Authors must accurately describe whether supporting data are:
-
Publicly available through an appropriate repository.
-
Available upon reasonable request.
-
Restricted because of ethical, legal, institutional, or privacy requirements.
-
Not applicable because no original research data were generated or analyzed.
Authors must not fabricate, falsify, selectively misrepresent, or manipulate research data.
For clinical trials subject to applicable ICMJE data-sharing requirements, authors must provide a clear data-sharing statement addressing the availability and conditions of access to de-identified individual participant data.
Where research data, code, protocols, questionnaires, or additional methodological materials are deposited in a repository, authors are encouraged to provide persistent identifiers and access links.
JIVR may request access to underlying research data, study protocols, statistical analyses, or supporting documents when necessary to investigate questions concerning the accuracy or integrity of published or submitted findings.
Authors must not disclose identifiable participant data or confidential information without appropriate authorization.
8. Plagiarism, Self-Plagiarism, and Text Recycling
JIVR has a strict policy against plagiarism and inappropriate reuse of previously published material.
8.1. Plagiarism
Plagiarism occurs when authors present the words, ideas, data, findings, or intellectual contributions of others as their own without appropriate acknowledgment.
Examples include:
-
Copying text without proper attribution.
-
Reproducing another author's ideas or research findings without citation.
-
Paraphrasing without acknowledging the original source.
-
Using figures, tables, illustrations, or photographs without appropriate attribution or permission.
-
Presenting another researcher's intellectual contribution as one's own.
All original sources must be appropriately cited.
8.2. Self-Plagiarism and Text Recycling
Authors must not present previously published material as new or original work without transparent disclosure and appropriate citation.
Substantial reuse of previously published text without adequate attribution may constitute text recycling or self-plagiarism.
The journal evaluates text recycling according to its extent, location, source, context, attribution, and potential impact on the originality of the submitted work.
Limited reuse of standard methodological descriptions may be acceptable in appropriate circumstances when the original publication is cited and the reuse does not misrepresent the novelty of the current research.
8.3. Similarity Screening
JIVR may use appropriate similarity-detection software to identify potential textual overlap between submissions and previously published or publicly available material.
Similarity reports are used as supporting evidence for editorial assessment and do not independently establish plagiarism.
A high similarity percentage does not automatically prove plagiarism, and a low similarity percentage does not guarantee the absence of plagiarism.
Editors consider the nature, source, extent, location, attribution, and scientific significance of the identified overlap.
JIVR does not use a single similarity percentage as an automatic threshold for manuscript acceptance or rejection.
8.4. Duplicate and Redundant Publication
JIVR does not accept duplicate or substantially redundant publications.
Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals.
Relevant overlap with previously published or submitted work must be disclosed and explained.
Publication of multiple articles based on the same dataset may be acceptable when each article addresses a sufficiently distinct research question and provides a meaningful additional scientific contribution.
Fragmentation of research findings into multiple publications without adequate scientific justification may constitute redundant publication.
8.5. Preprints and Previous Dissemination
Authors must disclose relevant preprints, conference abstracts, posters, and other forms of prior dissemination.
Preprint availability does not automatically constitute duplicate publication. However, authors must transparently identify the preprint and provide its persistent identifier or URL.
The Editor will assess eligibility in accordance with the journal's policies and applicable ICMJE recommendations.
9. Research Misconduct: Fabrication, Falsification, and Other Unethical Practices
JIVR considers research misconduct a serious breach of scientific integrity.
Forms of misconduct include, but are not limited to:
Data Fabrication
Inventing research data, participants, observations, results, or experimental findings that were never obtained.
Data Falsification
Manipulating research materials, procedures, or data, or selectively altering or omitting findings in ways that misrepresent the research record.
Inappropriate Image Manipulation
Manipulating scientific images, photographs, microscopy images, gels, radiological images, or other visual materials in ways that distort or misrepresent the underlying evidence.
Citation Manipulation
Adding irrelevant references, coercive citations, excessive self-citation, or citation practices intended to manipulate journal or author citation metrics rather than improve scientific accuracy.
Publication and Authorship Misconduct
Engaging in plagiarism, duplicate publication, ghost authorship, guest authorship, undisclosed contributions, or inappropriate changes to authorship.
Undisclosed Conflicts of Interest
Intentionally withholding relevant financial, professional, personal, or institutional relationships that could influence the research or publication process.
Peer-Review Manipulation
Providing fabricated reviewer identities or contact details, attempting to influence reviewer selection improperly, or manipulating the peer-review process through fraudulent or deceptive practices.
JIVR may investigate any credible indication of these or other serious breaches of research integrity.
Suspected misconduct is assessed individually and according to the available evidence.
10. Image Integrity and Scientific Illustrations
Authors must ensure that all figures, images, photographs, and other visual materials accurately represent the underlying research data.
Image processing and adjustments must not distort, obscure, selectively remove, or introduce scientific information.
The following practices are unacceptable:
-
Selective removal or addition of image elements.
-
Undisclosed manipulation of brightness, contrast, or color that changes scientific interpretation.
-
Duplication or inappropriate alteration of image components.
-
Fabrication or falsification of visual evidence.
-
Misrepresentation of experimental or clinical images.
Any image processing that could affect interpretation must be transparently described.
Authors must retain original and unprocessed image files and provide them to the Editorial Office when requested.
The journal may request original image files or additional supporting documentation when concerns arise.
11. Funding and Competing Interests
JIVR requires full and transparent disclosure of financial and non-financial relationships that may influence or appear to influence research or editorial judgments.
Authors must disclose:
-
Research grants and financial support.
-
Sponsor involvement in study design and conduct.
-
Relationships with commercial organizations.
-
Employment and consultancy.
-
Honoraria and speaker fees.
-
Stock ownership and patents.
-
Personal, academic, and institutional relationships that may constitute competing interests.
A declaration of no competing interests must be provided when no relevant conflicts exist.
Reviewers and Editors must also disclose relevant competing interests and must decline involvement when a conflict could compromise impartiality.
Funding sources must not influence the journal's independent editorial decisions.
12. Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies
JIVR follows applicable ICMJE recommendations concerning the responsible use of artificial intelligence and AI-assisted technologies in scholarly publishing.
Authors must disclose the use of relevant AI technologies in preparing or producing their manuscripts.
Where applicable, the disclosure should identify:
-
The AI tool or system.
-
The organization or provider, where known.
-
The purpose of its use.
-
The relevant research or manuscript components affected.
AI-assisted writing should be disclosed in the Acknowledgements section, while AI use in data collection, analysis, figure generation, or other research procedures should be described in the Methods section, as appropriate.
AI systems must not be listed as authors or co-authors.
Authors remain fully responsible for all content generated or assisted by AI technologies, including accuracy, originality, references, data integrity, and appropriate attribution.
AI must not be used to fabricate data, falsify findings, produce misleading research images, or create false references.
Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or unpublished research information to external AI systems that are not specifically authorized by the journal for secure editorial use.
Editors must maintain human oversight and remain fully responsible for editorial decisions, including decisions involving AI-assisted tools.
13. Responsibilities and Ethical Conduct of Peer Reviewers
Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scientific quality and integrity of JIVR.
Reviewers must:
-
Evaluate manuscripts objectively and impartially.
-
Assess scientific quality, methodology, originality, and ethical acceptability.
-
Provide clear, constructive, and evidence-based comments.
-
Identify relevant published research that has not been appropriately cited.
-
Report potential plagiarism, data manipulation, unethical research, or other integrity concerns confidentially to the responsible Editor.
-
Maintain strict confidentiality of submitted manuscripts and review materials.
-
Declare relevant competing interests.
-
Decline assignments when they lack appropriate expertise or cannot complete the review within the required period.
-
Avoid inappropriate citation requests designed primarily to increase their own or others' citation counts.
Reviewers must not:
-
Share unpublished manuscripts or review materials without authorization.
-
Use unpublished information for personal or professional advantage.
-
Contact authors directly about confidential submissions without editorial authorization.
-
Delegate peer reviews to other individuals without prior permission from the Editor.
-
Use AI systems to process confidential manuscript material without explicit journal authorization and adequate confidentiality safeguards.
Reviewer reports must be professional, respectful, and free from discriminatory, personal, or inappropriate comments.
14. Responsibilities and Ethical Conduct of Editors
Editors are responsible for ensuring fair, confidential, impartial, and timely editorial handling.
The Editor-in-Chief and other responsible Editors must:
-
Maintain editorial independence.
-
Apply journal policies consistently.
-
Assess submissions according to scientific and ethical merit.
-
Protect the confidentiality of manuscripts and reviewer identities.
-
Ensure that appropriate reviewers are selected.
-
Evaluate potential conflicts of interest.
-
Handle allegations of misconduct appropriately.
-
Avoid discriminatory or preferential editorial decisions.
-
Maintain the accuracy and integrity of the published scientific record.
Editorial decisions must not be influenced by commercial interests, institutional pressure, personal relationships, political considerations, or the anticipated impact of an article on citation metrics.
14.1. Editorial Conflicts of Interest
Editors must not handle manuscripts when they have a relevant personal, professional, financial, or institutional conflict of interest.
Manuscripts submitted by the Editor-in-Chief, Editors, or editorial board members must be assigned to an independent qualified Editor without relevant conflicts of interest.
The submitting Editor must not participate in reviewer selection, confidential editorial discussions, or publication decisions concerning their own manuscript.
The same scientific and ethical requirements applicable to other submissions must be applied to manuscripts submitted by editorial board members.
15. Confidentiality and Protection of Unpublished Information
All submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial communications, and unpublished research information are treated as confidential.
Editors, reviewers, and editorial staff must not disclose confidential submission information to unauthorized individuals.
Unpublished information obtained through the editorial process must not be used for personal, professional, or research advantage.
Author identities and reviewer identities must be protected in accordance with the journal's double-anonymous peer-review procedures.
Personal data and sensitive participant information must be handled according to the journal's Privacy Statement and applicable data-protection requirements.
16. Handling Allegations of Publication Misconduct
JIVR takes all credible allegations of research or publication misconduct seriously, whether raised before or after publication.
Allegations may concern authors, reviewers, Editors, editorial staff, or other participants in the publication process.
The journal follows a fair, evidence-based, and confidential procedure.
The process may include:
Step 1. Initial Assessment
The Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately appointed independent Editor evaluates the allegation and available supporting evidence.
Allegations must be sufficiently specific to permit meaningful assessment. Anonymous allegations are not automatically disregarded if they contain credible and verifiable information.
Step 2. Preliminary Investigation
Where appropriate, the journal reviews relevant documents, similarity reports, data, images, correspondence, and other available evidence.
A similarity percentage or an unsupported accusation alone is not considered conclusive evidence of misconduct.
Step 3. Request for Explanation
The corresponding author or relevant individual is contacted and given an appropriate opportunity to respond to the concerns.
Step 4. Further Investigation
When the response does not resolve the concern, or when the matter requires institutional investigation, the journal may contact the relevant institution, research organization, funder, or other competent authority.
The journal may request supporting documents or further clarification.
Step 5. Editorial Decision
After evaluating the available information, the journal determines the appropriate action.
Depending on the nature and seriousness of the matter, actions may include:
-
No further action where the concern is not substantiated.
-
Requesting clarification or documentation.
-
Requesting correction or revision.
-
Rejecting the submitted manuscript.
-
Suspending editorial consideration.
-
Informing the relevant institution or research organization.
-
Publishing an Expression of Concern.
-
Publishing a Correction or Retraction, where justified.
-
Taking other appropriate editorial action.
Step 6. Documentation and Confidentiality
Relevant correspondence, evidence, responses, and decisions should be documented and retained appropriately.
Investigations must be conducted fairly and confidentially, while protecting the rights of all parties involved.
The journal aims to correct the scholarly record whenever a substantiated problem affects the reliability, accuracy, or integrity of published work.
17. Complaints and Appeals
JIVR provides a process for handling complaints and appeals concerning editorial decisions, reviewer conduct, publication ethics, authorship, and journal procedures.
Authors may submit an appeal when they believe that:
-
A significant factual or methodological misunderstanding affected the decision.
-
Relevant scientific evidence was overlooked.
-
A serious procedural irregularity occurred.
-
A conflict of interest compromised the fairness of the editorial process.
Appeals must include a clear explanation and relevant supporting information.
Complaints may also be submitted by authors, reviewers, readers, institutions, or other concerned parties.
Complaints involving the Editor-in-Chief should, where practicable, be referred to an independent editorial or publishing authority.
All complaints and appeals will be assessed fairly and confidentially.
The outcome of an appeal is normally final.
18. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions
JIVR is committed to maintaining the accuracy, transparency, and integrity of the published scholarly record.
18.1. Corrections
A Correction may be published when an error in a published article affects accuracy, completeness, or clarity but does not invalidate the principal findings or conclusions.
Corrections should clearly identify the original article and describe the error and its correction.
Authors are expected to notify the Editorial Office promptly when significant errors are identified in their published work.
18.2. Expressions of Concern
An Expression of Concern may be published when substantial questions arise regarding the reliability or integrity of a published article and the investigation is ongoing or insufficient evidence is available to reach a final conclusion.
Such notices alert readers to unresolved concerns that may affect interpretation of the published research.
18.3. Retractions
An article may be retracted when credible evidence demonstrates that its findings or conclusions are substantially unreliable or that serious publication or research misconduct has compromised the scholarly record.
Grounds for retraction may include:
-
Fabrication or falsification of data.
-
Serious methodological or analytical errors.
-
Plagiarism or substantial redundant publication.
-
Serious ethical violations.
-
Inappropriate manipulation of research images or data.
-
Other circumstances that fundamentally compromise the reliability of the published work.
Retraction decisions are made by the Editor-in-Chief or an appropriately appointed independent editorial authority following an assessment of the available evidence.
Retraction notices must clearly identify the original article and explain the reasons for retraction.
Where technically possible, the original article remains accessible but must be clearly labelled as retracted, with links between the article and the retraction notice.
Retraction is intended to correct the scholarly record and protect readers, not to punish authors.
JIVR follows the relevant ICMJE recommendations and COPE guidance when considering corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions.
19. Post-Publication Discussion and Scientific Debate
JIVR encourages responsible scientific discussion and constructive academic debate concerning published research.
Readers may raise evidence-based concerns, provide methodological comments, or discuss the implications of published findings through appropriate scholarly correspondence.
Where appropriate, authors of the original article should be given an opportunity to respond.
Post-publication concerns will be evaluated by the responsible Editor and may lead to further editorial investigation or correction of the scholarly record.
Scientific disagreement alone does not constitute research misconduct.
20. Editorial Independence and Financial Considerations
JIVR maintains editorial independence in all publication decisions.
The journal's financial arrangements, publication model, and institutional relationships must not compromise scientific evaluation or editorial judgment.
JIVR does not charge authors submission fees, Article Processing Charges (APCs), or publication fees under its current publication fee policy.
No manuscript may receive preferential or unfavorable editorial treatment because of an author's financial status, institutional affiliation, or ability to pay.
Editorial decisions are based exclusively on scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, ethical integrity, and relevance to the journal's scope.
21. Related Journal Policies
This policy should be read together with the following dedicated JIVR policies:
-
Author Guidelines: Authorship, manuscript preparation, ethical declarations, data availability, and reporting requirements.
-
Submissions: Online submission procedures and mandatory files.
-
Editorial and Publication Policies: General editorial principles and publication governance.
-
Peer Review Policy: Reviewer selection, double-anonymous review, confidentiality, and editorial decision-making.
-
Open Access Policy: Open-access publishing, copyright, and licensing.
-
Publication Fees: Submission, processing, and publication fee information.
-
Privacy Statement: Collection, use, and protection of personal information.
-
Archiving and Digital Preservation Policy: Long-term preservation of published articles.
The policies are intended to provide a consistent and transparent framework for responsible scholarly publishing.
22. International Ethical Standards and Resources
JIVR encourages all authors, reviewers, and editors to consult the following authoritative resources:
International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)
Recommendations for the Conduct, Reporting, Editing, and Publication of Scholarly Work in Medical Journals.
https://www.icmje.org/recommendations/
Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
Core Practices for publication ethics.
https://publicationethics.org/core-practices
World Medical Association (WMA)
Declaration of Helsinki.
https://www.wma.net/what-we-do/medical-ethics/declaration-of-helsinki/
EQUATOR Network
Reporting guidelines for health research.
https://www.equator-network.org/
JIVR periodically reviews this policy to maintain alignment with recognized international recommendations and developments in research and publication ethics.
Reference to the guidance of these organizations does not, by itself, imply formal membership or accreditation.
23. Contact for Ethical Concerns
Questions, complaints, or allegations concerning publication ethics, research integrity, authorship, peer review, or editorial conduct may be directed to:
Journal of Injury and Violence Research (JIVR)
Editorial Office
Email: jivr1@jivresearch.org
Website: https://jivresearch.org/jivr/
Correspondents are encouraged to provide the manuscript title, article DOI, or OJS submission identification number, where applicable, and to include relevant supporting information.
All concerns will be considered in accordance with the journal's ethical and editorial policies.